Do High Protein, Low Carb Diets Work?
High protein, low carb diets cause the greatest appetite reduction.
Low carbohydrate, restricted calorie diets have successfully been shown to enhance weight loss compared to standard or higher carbohydrate intakes, because they work indirectly by dramatic food restriction via appetite suppression. One of the theories behind high protein, low carb diets is the increased thermic effect of protein. According to a few studies, the thermic effect of protein is 25-35 percent of calories, but it is only 5-15 percent for carbohydrates. Fat is about equal to or less than carbs, depending on the type. In a meta-analysis of 1,416 subjects, low-carb diets (50-150g of carbs per day) led to more fat loss compared to placebo. There has been debate as to what macronutrient is causing the most significant reduction in appetite: is it protein or carbs?
Researchers analyzed which combination of the carbohydrate and protein proportions in the diet would show the greatest bodyweight and fat loss. Appetite, caloric intake, body weight, and fat mass were measured in 19 subjects placed sequentially on the following diets:
– High-protein, low-carbohydrate/high fat of 20 percent protein, 25 percent carbohydrates, 55 percent fat.
– High protein, normal carbohydrate, normal fat of 20 percent protein, 50 percent carbs, 30 percent fat.
– Normal protein, low carbohydrate/high fat of 10 percent protein, 25 percent carbohydrates, 65 percent fat.
– Normal-protein, normal carbohydrate, normal fat of 10 percent protein, 50 percent carbs, 40 percent fat.
At the end of the study, all four diets contributed to weight loss; however; it showed irrefutably, that, despite the success all-over with all four diets, the answer is that it is the relatively high-protein content per se, that supports the even greater success, and not the relatively lower carbohydrate content. Appetite suppression was markedly increased with the isocaloric high-protein diet. After the research was crunched, the specific comparisons showed that the two high protein diets, namely high protein, normal carbohydrates vs. high protein, low carb and the two standard protein diets, namely normal protein/normal carbohydrates vs. normal protein/low carb did not show significantly different effects. Both high protein diets resulted in enhanced fat loss and body weight loss compared to the normal protein diets. In sum, the researchers showed that body-weight loss and weight-maintenance depends on the high-protein (a relatively high-protein content of 1.1 vs. 0.7 g/kg BW), but not on the ‘low-carb’ component of the diet, while it is unrelated to the concomitant fat-content of the diet.
Soenen S, Bonomi AG, Lemmens SG, Scholte J, Thijssen MA, van Berkum F, Westerterp-Plantenga MS. Relatively high-protein or ‘low-carb’ energy-restricted diets for body weight loss and body weight maintenance? Physiol Behav. 2012 Oct 10;107(3):374-80.
Lejeune MP, Kovacs EM, Westerterp-Plantenga MS. Additional protein intake limits weight regain after weight loss in humans. Br J Nutr 2005;93:281-9.
Weigle DS, Breen PA, Matthys CC, Callahan HS, Meeuws KE, Burden VR. A high-protein diet induces sustained reductions in appetite, ad libitum caloric intake, and body weight despite compensatory changes in diurnal plasma leptin and ghrelin concentrations. Am J Clin Nutr 2005;82:41-8.
Due A, Toubro S, Skov AR, Astrup A. Effect of normal-fat diets, either medium or high in protein, on body weight in overweight subjects: a randomised 1-year trial. Int J Obes Relat Metab Disord 2004;28:1283-90.
Jéquier E. Pathways to obesity. Int J Obes Relat Metab Disord. 2002;26 Suppl 2:S12–7.
Halton T, Hu F. The effects of high protein diets on thermogenesis, satiety and weight loss: a critical review. J Am Coll Nutr. 2004;23(5):373–85.
Hashimoto Y, Fukuda T, Oyabu C, Tanaka M, Asano M, Yamazaki M, et al. Impact of low-carbohydrate diet on body composition: meta-analysis of randomized controlled studies. Obes Rev. 2016;17(6):499–509.